# Staged identity portraits (She Who Tells a Story)

> An atlas-selected comparison of three staged-portrait series within She Who Tells a Story, not a museum-named movement or one Iranian or Arab look. Frontal, deliberately still figures, selected clothes and backdrops turn the portrait into an argument about representation. Historical costume meets a modern prop; writing can join body and room; repeated sittings alter dress and visibility. Unlike cinematic staged tableau, the serial portrait and its controlled substitutions carry the argument, not a figure caught in an unresolved scene.

- Period: 1998–2010
- Where it began: An atlas-selected, three-series formal comparison within the documented exhibition She Who Tells a Story
- Kind: Staged & conceptual
- Page: https://lumogeny.com/styles/mena-staged-identity-photography/

## How the look is made

- Keep the portrait frontal and deliberately still; let the sitter meet the lens when the face is visible rather than act an incidental cinematic gesture.
- Make one selected garment, object or background do conceptual work, and keep its relationship to the sitter legible.
- Repeat a stable framing across a series so that a change of dress, prop or visibility becomes readable through comparison.
- Keep fabric, hands and selected objects in focus, with controlled light that preserves their texture rather than dissolving them into atmosphere.
- Retain the sitter's agency and the work's specific context; explain the construction instead of presenting a staged image as a candid cultural document.

## How it is lit

- Reconstruction of the dark-backdrop portrait branch: place a broad source above and to camera left, with restrained fill; let the far cheek and black cloth darken while retaining facial and fabric detail. This describes the observed light, not a documented rig.
- Reconstruction of the pale, text-covered set branch: use a broad, gently directional source and ample room fill so pale cloth remains distinct from the pale wall through soft fold shadows, without burning out its markings.

### A light plan from its choices (schematic)

- Key: a softbox, about 40° to the camera’s left, high, soft.

## Camera settings

50–85 mm · f/5.6–f/11 · 1/125–1/60 s · ISO 100–400 (on full-frame), inferred. Illustrative modern full-frame reconstruction ranges for a motionless portrait with readable cloth and props, not measured historical typical settings or a contributor's recipe. No specimen exposure, lens, camera or sensitivity was confirmed; use a tripod and adjust to actual illumination. The occasional large-format trait concerns one film-based branch, not the format of these reconstruction ranges.

## Directing people

Hold a frontal seated or standing portrait, with hands resting or carrying a selected object and an unsmiling or restrained expression; a visible face often meets the lens. Groups may hold one another in a stable arrangement across successive frames. Covered faces and the final empty frame in one sequence are meaningful exceptions, not a universal gaze or pose to impose.

## Styling

Select clothes, fabric, background and props to make a specific argument: a historic studio quotation with a modern object, a pale room and garment physically inscribed with henna before exposure, or a controlled sequence of the sitter's own and borrowed clothes against black. These are different branches, not a combined costume recipe; writing on the photographed set is styling, not a text-overlay finish. Do not treat a person's ordinary religious dress as fancy dress, and do not copy culturally specific script or sacred motifs as decoration.

## Before you shoot it

These are authored works by distinct Iranian, Moroccan and Yemeni women, including diaspora artists, not a single Islamic, Arab or Middle Eastern aesthetic. Iran is not interchangeable with the Arab world. Read the artists' accounts and retain their names, collaborators and contexts; commission and credit living practitioners rather than generating substitutes for their work. No generated imitation is appropriate for this entry. Do not copy a named artist's calligraphic surfaces, historic-costume combinations or family sequence, fabricate testimony or imply a synthetic person represents a real community. Do not reduce a hijab to oppression or use religious dress, henna or Arabic/Persian writing as exotic decoration; the languages and practices are not interchangeable. Almutawakel explicitly resists anti-veil stereotypes, and her sequence involves her real daughter: its staged political argument is not a general document of Muslim women's lives. NMWA records that other prospective sitters withdrew when they learned the photographs would be exhibited, making informed consent, the right to decline public exposure and protection from social or political harm central. Keep the specimens link-only unless an exact-file open licence is established. This entry excludes documentary and conflict images from the same exhibition and does not authorise simulated news or historical evidence.

## A prompt for an image model

No prompt for this style. Behind its pictures: caution asks to commission and credit living practitioners rather than generate substitutes. Authored portraits include a real child and consent-sensitive testimony.

## Photographs

- Shadi Ghadirian, Untitled from the Qajar Series (Sitting woman with Pepsi can), 1998. Los Angeles County Museum of Art, M.2008.35.9, purchased with acquisition funds and donor support listed on the object record. © Shadi Ghadirian; digital image © Museum Associates/LACMA. In copyright; link only. In copyright, linked: https://collections.lacma.org/object/140420
- Lalla Essaydi, Converging Territories #21B, 2004. Los Angeles County Museum of Art, M.2019.391.2, gift of Jan and Trish de Bont. © Lalla Essaydi; digital courtesy Museum Associates/LACMA. In copyright; link only. In copyright, linked: https://collections.lacma.org/object/265868
- Boushra Almutawakel, Mother, Daughter, Doll, 2010, nine pigment prints, each 24 × 16 in. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, 2013.556–564, museum purchase with funds donated by Richard and Lucille Spagnuolo. Artwork © Boushra Almutawakel; reproduction photograph © 2015 MFA Boston, as credited by NMWA. In copyright; link only. In copyright, linked: https://nmwa.org/blog/nmwa-exhibitions/she-who-tells-a-story-boushra-almutawakel/

## Sources

- https://nmwa.org/press/nmwa-presents-she-who-tells-story-women-photographers-iran-and-arab-world/ — institutional exhibition account, retrieved also through the museum's WordPress API press/16678: Boston and Washington dates; distinct categories of deconstructing Orientalism, constructing identities and new documentary; 1993–97 precursor, 2010 sequence and 2012 triptych. Documents the broader curatorial grouping, not a museum-defined three-series subset or a unified school. The atlas selects this comparison; the 2012 triptych is outside its upright/serial core and does not date this entry.
- https://nmwa.org/exhibitions/she-who-tells-story/ — exhibition record: 8 April–31 July 2016, twelve contributors, serial narratives and the explicit range from portraiture through documentary to staged narratives.
- https://collections.lacma.org/object/140420 — Shadi Ghadirian, Untitled from the Qajar Series (Sitting woman with Pepsi can), 1998, M.2008.35.9, gelatin-silver bromide print; curator explains vintage dress, painted backdrops, modern props and irony. Exact image inspected; copyright Shadi Ghadirian, publicDomain 0. No capture settings supplied.
- https://nmwa.org/blog/nmwa-exhibitions/she-who-tells-a-story-shadi-ghadirian/ — museum account, retrieved through API posts/8623: Qajar 1998–99, 33 photographs, archival studio references, family and friends as sitters, sepia and consciously chosen props; contextualises the Iranian portrait strand without asserting a shared camera recipe.
- https://collections.lacma.org/object/265868 — Lalla Essaydi, Converging Territories #21B, 2004, M.2019.391.2, dye coupler prints mounted to aluminum, gift of Jan and Trish de Bont. Exact image inspected: one covered standing figure, text across cloth and surroundings, pale muted colour and visible sheet-film border. Copyright Lalla Essaydi, publicDomain 0; no capture exposure supplied.
- https://www.lallaessaydi.com/news/PDFS/Catalogs/Crossroads_Exhibition_2008.pdf — artist's interview with Ray Waterhouse in Crossroads, 13–25 October 2008: Converging Territories photographed in a Moroccan family house; Les Femmes du Maroc in the Boston studio; physical henna writing on walls, cloth and sitters, rehearsals and collaboration. It specifically rejects treating the artist as representative of all Arab women. The lettering was physically prepared on the cloth and set before exposure and is described under styling; it is not evidence of a text-overlay finish. The interview distinguishes segmentation that presents stages of life from a triptych elongating a reclining figure; the reclining branch is outside this entry's selected core.
- https://nmwa.org/blog/nmwa-exhibitions/she-who-tells-a-story-boushra-almutawakel/ — museum account, retrieved through API posts/8570: Mother, Daughter, Doll, 2010, nine pigment prints, MFA Boston 2013.556–564, credits and full series image. Exact nine-panel reproduction inspected. Records the artist and eldest daughter as sitters, prospective sitters' refusal of exhibition, own/borrowed clothes, the final empty pedestal and the artist's rejection of anti-veil stereotypes. No exposure or camera supplied.
- https://www.mfa.org/sites/default/files/2019-07/mfa-traveling-exhibitions_she-who-tells-a-story.pdf — organising museum's traveling-exhibition dossier corroborates authorship, 2010 date, pigment-print medium and copyright for Mother, Daughter, Doll. Its preliminary APP.2013.197 number is not substituted for the accession range given in the later NMWA caption.

---

From Lumogeny (https://lumogeny.com/), a service of Van Riel Online Services. The shoot sheet for your own camera, lenses and lights is on the page: https://lumogeny.com/styles/mena-staged-identity-photography/#sheet
