lumogeny Search

Styles / Staged & conceptual

Appropriation and rephotography

1977–present. New York. Also called Rephotography or Photographic appropriation.

Where the lights stand
seen from above1 open skycameraSchematic, not to scale
  1. Key: the open sky, all around and above, soft.

Schematic, not to scale: worked out from the style’s choices. No set-up of this style has been rendered yet.

Where you have seen it

The photographs that define it are still in copyright, so they are linked below rather than shown.

Pictures of pictures: the artist re-shoots an advertisement, a magazine page or a catalogue plate, crops out the logo and text, and enlarges it until the copy's grain, halftone and soft focus show. The subject, the pose and the light belong to the source (a cowboy at sunset, a model's stare, a tenant family), and the artist adds no scene of their own. Prints are shown large, in series, as a critique of selling and of authorship.

Built mostly on one system: Deadpan document. What systems are.

How the look is made

  1. Choose a picture someone else made for the mass media, such as an advertisement, a magazine page or a catalogue plate, and photograph that picture, not a scene.
  2. Copy it flat and square-on: fill the frame with the picture, level and evenly lit so no glare or shadow of your own lands on it, and crop away the logo, caption and margins.
  3. Leave the source's pose, styling and light alone, and add no prop, retouch or new arrangement; the model's smile, the cowboy's silhouette and the sunset stay as sold.
  4. Enlarge far past the original size and let the copy's grain, halftone, soft focus and shifted colour show as the picture's own texture.
  5. Print and show in a series of the same kind of picture at gallery scale, so repetition exposes the formula behind them.
  6. Keep a deadpan face: make no comment inside the frame, and let the act of taking the picture question who made it and who owns it.

Shoot sheet for your kit

Fill in your camera, lenses and lights, and the sheet says which light plays each part, what to work around and where to start on your camera. Without a kit it starts on a full-frame camera.

Step 1

Light

1 open skycameraSchematic, not to scale
  1. Key: the open sky, all around and above, soft.

Shape & form
Light from the camera’s own position (an on-camera flash, a ring light, a frontal softbox) fills every hollow, so faces and objects look flat, with little shape.

How the style is lit

  • A copy stand or a wall: the page or print hung flat and lit evenly from two sides at 45 degrees, so no glare or shadow of your own falls on it.
  • The source's own light, kept as found: an advertisement's low golden sun, a studio model's soft key, a documentary photograph's flat daylight.

This plan is worked out from the style’s choices, so it is drawn as a schematic. One way to get the light, not a record of how any photograph was lit.

Step 2

Lens and settings

Start at

50 mmf/111/15 sISO 200

On a full-frame camera: the same depth of field and exposure as the style’s own numbers, in the same light. Then meter and adjust.

  • 1/15 s: on a tripod.
Then
40–60 mm · f/8–f/16 · 1/125–0.5 s · ISO 100–400 on full frame, inferred from the gear and the look. No photographer's settings were found stated; these are the sensible numbers for copying a flat print on a stand: a normal lens, stopped down so the page stays sharp edge to edge, with a tripod allowing slower shutter speeds. Light and exposure vary with the copy set-up. Format is the nominal full-frame equivalent for film copying.
White balance
Daylight-balanced film or sensor, lit to match, so the source's printed dyes (a sunset's oranges and reds) are left as printed, not corrected.
Focal length
Roughly the eye’s own perspective; no visible distortion.
Focus
A soft glow around highlights; edges never quite sharp.
Angle
The camera at the height of a standing person or of the subject.
Distance
Whole figures and their immediate surroundings.
Balance
The subject faces the lens; planes run parallel to the picture.
Crop & fill
The edges cut into the subject: heads, limbs or objects run out of frame.
Depth
Depth collapsed into pattern and flat shapes.
Instant
Movement stopped dead by a fast shutter or flash.
Duration
An unmoving scene, exposed slowly and carefully.
Step 3

Direct

Nobody poses for the artist: the people are the ones in the source picture, and they keep what they were given there, such as a model's direct stare and hand-on-hip pose, a cowboy's profile against the sky, or a tenant family's formal, square-on gaze. Where the source has no figure, the object is the subject.

Turn to the camera
Shoulders and hips face the lens straight on: direct, symmetrical, sometimes confrontational.
Line & energy
Rigid and motionless, sometimes braced against a head rest or gripping a chair: held for a long exposure or a solemn occasion.
The moment
Existing images taken over and photographed again.
With the sitter
Neutral, unemotional and distant.
Step 4

Style the set

Nothing is styled by the artist. The clothes, props, sets and make-up are those the original advertisement or documentary job put in front of its camera, such as a hat and lasso, a gleaming product, a glossy face or a work-worn coat, and they are copied exactly as found.

How much is styled
Nothing dressed, made up, moved or added for the picture.
Step 5

Finish

Colour
Strong, dense colours.
Film
Printed colour negatives: soft, forgiving colour.
Texture
Film grain or noise you can see at normal size.
Post-production
Nothing changed beyond exposure and development.
Shown as
Pictures made and shown as a set.
Shown in
Large prints on the wall, like paintings.

Stay away from candid & unobserved, directed scene & tableau, constructed set & miniature, direct on-camera flash, composite & montage, clean & noiseless, hyper-detailed, tilted angle, wide angle, sell & persuade and lyrical & poetic.

Before you shoot it

Rephotographed pictures usually show real, identifiable people: models in advertisements, and the families and workers of documentary projects, who never agreed to be copied into a different argument. Treat the sitters in the source as people, not material, and never alter their picture to mock them. Appropriation raises live questions of copyright and authorship: Walker Evans's estate viewed Levine's series as copyright infringement and acquired it, and a court case over Prince's use of another photographer's pictures was mixed: the Second Circuit in 2013 found 25 of 30 works fair use and sent five back to the lower court, and the case settled in 2014. Do not copy a living photographer's or a living person's picture without permission, credit or a clear transformation. Several source pictures, such as the tenant family in the Evans plates Levine copied, include children; never rephotograph pictures of children, of private people or of recent harm for effect, and do not use the form to launder a real person's image.

A prompt for an image model

No prompt for this style

Behind its pictures: the method copies other people's photographs of real families, workers and children.

Its caution asks to get permission from and credit living photographers rather than imitate.

Rephotographed pictures usually show real, identifiable people: models in advertisements, and the families and workers of documentary projects, who never agreed to be copied into a different argument. Treat the sitters in the source as people, not material, and never alter their picture to mock them. Do not copy a living photographer's or a living person's picture without permission, credit or a clear transformation. never rephotograph pictures of children, of private people or of recent harm for effect, and do not use the form to launder a real person's image. A generated image in this style must show invented sources and invented people, be labelled as AI-generated, and never pass as a real advertisement, a real brand's campaign or a real artist's work.

Work with photographers of this tradition, or take only its light and lens (the shoot sheet above) without its people, places or rituals.

Where to see it

From open collections, shown whole with their credits. Later photographs are linked, not shown, while they are in copyright.

In copyright, so linked

With other styles

The opposite: Staged tableau photography. Choose the tableau when you build a new scene with actors and sets; choose rephotography when you build nothing and let a finished picture stand in for the scene.

Pairs with FSA/OWI documentary photography. Rephotograph a documentary classic to ask who owns a famous picture: crop away the logo and caption as Prince does, or keep the whole catalogue plate as Levine does, and let its original square-on gaze carry the weight.

The opposite: New Color photography. Both can use saturated colour, but the New Color photographer makes their own deadpan pictures of the world, while here the colour is the shifted print of an advertisement.

Pairs with New Topographics. Share a flat, deadpan, series-driven attitude; swap your own frontal landscapes for found ones and let the repetition make the point.

Pairs with Picture-magazine photo essay. The magazine page is the raw material: copy its pictures flat, cropped of captions, to turn a photo essay's rhetoric back on itself.

The opposite: E-commerce packshot on white. A packshot makes a product look as sold, with clean and sharp results; the rephotograph copies a product ad until its grain and glamour become visible.

Sources

  1. Pictures Generation, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pictures_Generation (Pictures, Artists Space, 24 September-29 October 1977, Troy Brauntuch, Jack Goldstein, Sherrie Levine, Robert Longo, Philip Smith; Crimp's essay on quotation, excerptation, framing and staging; The Pictures Generation, 1974-1984, Metropolitan Museum of Art, 29 April-2 August 2009; Pictures Revisited 2020-21)
  2. Sherrie Levine, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherrie_Levine (rephotographed Walker Evans's images from an exhibition catalogue; shown at Metro Pictures, 1981; the Evans estate's copyright objection; the Met now owns the whole series)
  3. Richard Prince, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Prince (Time Inc. library work from 1973; first solo show at CEPA, Buffalo, June 1980; Marlboro cowboy series blown up at a commercial lab; Cariou v. Prince, settled 2014)
  4. After Walker Evans: 2, Sherrie Levine, Metropolitan Museum of Art: https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/267209 (1981, gelatin silver print, 9.6 x 12.8 cm, gift of the artist, 1995; Met open-access API record) [link-only, not public domain, image not viewed]
  5. Untitled (cowboy), Richard Prince, Metropolitan Museum of Art: https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/283742 (1989, chromogenic print, 127 x 177.8 cm; Met API record tags advertisements, horses, men) [link-only, not public domain, image not viewed]

Try

For adults only

This picture shows adult bodies: lingerie, nudity or sensual poses. Lumogeny shows these pictures only to people aged 18 or older.

Your answer stays in this browser.