Styles / Documentary & reportage
Chinese socialist realist photography
- Key: the open sky, all around and above, soft.
- Fill: a softbox, about 25° to the camera’s right, high, soft.
Open shadows: bright surroundings (walls, ground, sky) fill them; no reflector needed. Shadowless: big sources close in on both sides (or a light tent, or a white cove) so nothing casts a shadow.
Schematic, not to scale: worked out from the style’s choices. No set-up of this style has been rendered yet.
The photographs that define it are still in copyright, so they are linked below rather than shown.
Official photographs of the People's Republic, 1949-1976, centred on the Mao cult: a leader at the centre of a managed, joyous crowd, uniformed soldiers, workers and students, banners and little red books as props. The black-and-white press print came first; the saturated, warm look belongs to later colour books and posters. Faces are lit openly, people are arranged and cued, prints retouched. Evidence is mostly of the leader.
Built mostly on one system: Event reportage. What systems are.
Shoot sheet for your kit A prompt for an image model The photographs
How the look is made
- Put the leader or the exemplary worker at the centre of the frame, on the middle axis, facing the camera, with the others turned towards them.
- Shoot from slightly below, so heroes stand above the horizon and against sky.
- Light faces evenly and openly in flat daylight or a bright studio, with no dark side and no hard shadow under the eyes.
- Cue the smiles: arrange people in uniform, raise the banner or the little red book, and direct the crowd so that most faces look up, pleased; the staging is managed, not wholly free of spontaneity.
- Retouch the print so skin is smooth and bright and colour is warm; leave out any frame that shows doubt, hardship or fear.
Shoot sheet for your kit
Fill in your camera, lenses and lights, and the sheet says which light plays each part, what to work around and where to start on your camera. Without a kit it starts on a full-frame camera.
Light
Key: the open sky, all around and above, soft.
Fill: a softbox, about 25° to the camera’s right, high, soft.
- Open shadows: bright surroundings (walls, ground, sky) fill them; no reflector needed.
- Shadowless: big sources close in on both sides (or a light tent, or a white cove) so nothing casts a shadow.
- Shadow edges
- Shadows that fade gradually from light to dark, cast by a large or diffused light: a window, a softbox, a cloudy sky. Light from all around, so almost no shadows form even under the chin or behind objects: a white cove, a light tent, a large ring light, fog over snow.
- Shadow depth
- Shadows kept light and full of detail by a reflector, a fill light, bounce or bright surroundings (a low lighting ratio, up to about 3:1: the shadow side at most a stop and a half darker).
How the style is lit
- Open daylight outdoors, a clear or lightly clouded sky, with the faces turned to the light and no fill needed.
- Bright, even lamps or flash for indoor leader portraits, with the face lit as the lightest thing in the room.
- Overcast or midday sun at rallies and in fields, with shadows allowed to fall under the hats and away from the faces.
This plan is worked out from the style’s choices, so it is drawn as a schematic. One way to get the light, not a record of how any photograph was lit.
Lens and settings
Start at
On a full-frame camera: the same depth of field and exposure as the style’s own numbers, in the same light. Then meter and adjust.
- The style’s f/11 on 6 × 6 cm gives about the depth of field of f/6.2 on full frame.
- Then
- 28–50 mm · f/8–f/16 · 1/500–1/100 s · ISO 50–400 on 6 × 6 cm, inferred from the gear and the look. Inferred from the look of the surviving prints (square, deep-focus, sunlit rally and field pictures) and the film of the period; no source consulted gives the cameras or settings. Roll-film and 35 mm cameras were the likely tools; apertures at f/8-f/16 on 6 x 6 keep the crowd sharp, and indoor portraits probably used lamps or flash at slower times. The 35 mm and 6 x 6 formats are not established for Hou Bo or any other photographer here; they stay a guess.
- White balance
- Daylight-balanced colour film, printed warm so that skin, red flags and badges glow; the sky is left a clean cool blue and the greens are left cool and dark.
- Focal length
- Roughly the eye’s own perspective; no visible distortion.
- Focus
- Everything sharp from the nearest stone to the horizon.
- Angle
- Looking up: the subject towers.
- Distance
- Whole figures and their immediate surroundings.
- Balance
- The subject in the middle, the frame balanced around it. The subject faces the lens; planes run parallel to the picture.
- Crop & fill
- The subject shown small within its setting, which explains it.
- Duration
- An unmoving scene, exposed slowly and carefully.
Direct
Leaders stand upright, square to the camera or walking towards it, with a raised hand, a wave or a calm half-smile, and people around them crowd in and look up at them. Workers, soldiers and students are arranged in rows or tight groups with smiles on every face, holding the little red book or a banner towards the lens. Nobody looks tired, afraid or away.
- Body position
- Upright, weight on both feet, shoulders level: the plain, even stance of a formal sitting or a line-up.
- Turn to the camera
- Shoulders and hips face the lens straight on: direct, symmetrical, sometimes confrontational.
- Head & gaze
- Face and eyes raised towards the light or the sky: hope, devotion, longing.
- Arms & hands
- Arms stretched out, pointing or waving, or hands caught mid-gesture while talking. Hands busy with a prop or a tool: flowers, a phone, a cup, a cigarette, an instrument, one’s own work.
- Expression
- A smile, posed or natural, lips closed or showing teeth.
- Several people
- Bodies close together, overlapping and leaning in: friends, a band, a family on a sofa.
- With the sitter
- The sitter arranged and still, facing the camera. The subject performs for the camera and shapes the picture.
- The set-up
- A scene staged and directed like a film still or a painting.
Style the set
Everyone is dressed in uniform or in plain, clean, buttoned work clothes: army-green tunics with red collar badges and a red star on the cap, grey-blue Mao suits, white shirts and straw hats for fields. Red armbands, banners, flags, lanterns, badges and the little red book are the props; faces carry no make-up but are retouched smooth, and the set (a square, a rice field, a factory floor, a bare room) is swept and made orderly.
- Clothes
- The clothes of a trade, a rank, a team or an institution. Simple, solid, unbranded clothes chosen so they do not distract from the face.
- Hair & make-up
- No visible make-up; skin, hair and blemishes as they are.
- Set & props
- Props chosen and placed for colour, texture and story: linen, ceramics, cutlery, flowers, scattered ingredients.
Finish
- Monochrome
- Rich blacks, clean whites and every grey between.
- Post-production
- Perfected skin and surfaces. Areas lightened and darkened by hand in printing.
- Shown as
- Each picture stands on its own.
- Shown in
- Pictures made for magazine pages and spreads.
Stay away from testimony & advocacy, ironic & humorous, melancholy, glamour & aspiration, low-key & chiaroscuro, deep shadows, black shadows, candid & unobserved, confrontational, awkward & in-between, tilted angle, high angle and straight print.
Before you shoot it
These photographs served a one-party state and a leader cult: they were made to praise Mao and the Party, and they leave out the famines, purges and violence of the same years, which Li Zhensheng's hidden negatives showed. Many people in the pictures are real, were cued to smile or took part under pressure, and some were later persecuted; some of the photographers or their families may be living, and the copyright is held. Show the originals with their context, credit the photographers, and set them beside the work that exposed the omissions.
A prompt for an image model
No prompt for this style
Behind its pictures: one-party state propaganda and a leader cult with real, often coerced people.
Caution forbids pictures that pass as news or glamorise the regime.
Many people in the pictures are real, were cued to smile or took part under pressure, and some were later persecuted; some of the photographers or their families may be living, and the copyright is held. Show the originals with their context, credit the photographers, and set them beside the work that exposed the omissions.
Work with photographers of this tradition, or take only its light and lens (the shoot sheet above) without its people, places or rituals.
Where to see it
From open collections, shown whole with their credits. Later photographs are linked, not shown, while they are in copyright.
In copyright, so linked
- Mao Zedong comes down from the Tiananmen rostrum to meet Red Guards , Meng Zhaorui (as credited on Wikimedia Commons), 1 October 1966. Wikimedia Commons (from Gonghe guo zhenhan shunjian, People's Literature Publishing House).
- Mao Zedong in a field of millet (file named 'rice field') , Credited to Hou Bo on the Commons page, which is inconsistent on authorship, c. 1950. Wikimedia Commons (from Quotations from Chairman Mao Tse-Tung).
- Mao Zedong playing table tennis , Unattributed; published in Quotations from Chairman Mao Tse-Tung, c. 1955. Wikimedia Commons (from Quotations from Chairman Mao Tse-Tung).
With other styles
The opposite: FSA/OWI documentary photography. FSA pictures also served a government but show hardship to argue for relief, in plain light and with captions; here every face smiles, so use FSA to see where propaganda would cut the frame.
Pairs with New Vision. New Vision's low, steep viewpoint and strong diagonal give a figure monumental height; here the angle is kept frontal and the figure centred.
The opposite: Hollywood glamour portraiture. Both flatter with light and retouching, but Hollywood sculpts the face with a key light and shadow to sell desire, where this style lights the face open and shadow-free to command loyalty.
Sources
- Photography in China, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photography_in_China (the state organised artists and writers into official groups; Hou Bo, Lu Houmin and Xu Xiaobing assigned to Mao; Cultural Revolution photography seen as a Socialist Realist propagandist tool; April Fifth 1976 amateurs and the April Photo Society; statements in this section are tagged citation needed)
- Hou Bo, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hou_Bo (1924-2017; in Zhongnanhai 1950-1961; The Founding of the PRC, 1 October 1949; Mao Zedong Swimming Across the Yangzi, 1955; 'Stalinesque' poses; 'court photographers'; a rice-field picture issued as a poster in millions in 1958; camera not stated)
- Li Zhensheng (photojournalist), Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Li_Zhensheng_(photojournalist) (Heilongjiang Daily policy of 'positive' images, mostly smiling revolutionaries praising Mao; hidden negatives; Red-Color News Soldier, 2003)
- Red-Color News Soldier, ICP: https://www.icp.org/index.php/content/red-color-news-soldier (the book as a visual history of the Cultural Revolution from negatives hidden for almost 40 years)
- The Mao Cult, chineseposters.net: https://chineseposters.net/themes/mao-cult (the hong guang liang rule, 'red, bright, shining', and the bright, haloed, up-looked-at Mao in posters and paintings; it concerns painted and printed imagery, not photography as such)
- Mao Zedong 19661001.jpg, Wikimedia Commons: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Mao_Zedong_19661001.jpg (credited to Meng Zhaorui, from Gonghe guo zhenhan shunjian; 1 October 1966; the licence tag and first publication are not documented)
- Mao Zedong ping pong.jpg and Mao Zedong rice field.jpg, Wikimedia Commons: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Mao_Zedong_ping_pong.jpg and https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Mao_Zedong_rice_field.jpg (both reproduced from Quotations from Chairman Mao Tse-Tung; the licence tags are unverified and the authorship is not settled)