Styles / Staged & conceptual
Old Master painterly portraiture
- Key: a window, about 60° to the camera’s left, soft.
- Black flag: a black card, about 60° to the camera’s right, soft.
No fill: a black card on the shadow side keeps the shadows dark (negative fill).
Schematic, not to scale: worked out from the style’s choices. No set-up of this style has been rendered yet.
The photographs that define it are still in copyright, so they are linked below rather than shown.
A still half-length or head-and-shoulders portrait that looks back to Dutch and Flemish painting of the 1600s: the sitter turned three-quarters, face composed and unsmiling, a cloth, bonnet or turban on the head and plain dark clothes, set against a near-black or mottled ground. One large soft light from high at one side models the face in slow gradations and lets the body sink into shadow. Colour is held back to blacks, umbers and pale skin with one accent, the file is retouched and sometimes composited, and the print is hung large, like a painting.
Built on two systems: Sculpted glamour and Styled tabletop. What systems are.
Shoot sheet for your kit A prompt for an image model The photographs Its portrait light in the lab
How the look is made
- Use one large, soft light (a big window, as the painters had, or a big softbox) high and to one side, a little in front of the sitter, and let nothing but a faint bounce reach the shadow side.
- Turn the body three-quarters away from the light and the face partly back, light the far cheek (short lighting), and let the shoulders and clothes fall into near-black.
- Put the sitter in front of a dark, plain or mottled ground, well back from it so little light reaches it, and leave a little space above the head.
- Dress the head and leave the rest plain: a folded cloth, bonnet, hood or turban, or period-style dressed hair, over dark, unbranded clothes, with natural or lightly groomed skin.
- Ask for stillness and a composed, unsmiling face, with the eyes meeting the lens calmly.
- Grade towards muted blacks, umbers and pale skin with a single saturated accent, model the face further by dodging and burning, and print it large.
Shoot sheet for your kit
Fill in your camera, lenses and lights, and the sheet says which light plays each part, what to work around and where to start on your camera. Without a kit it starts on a full-frame camera.
Light
Key: a window, about 60° to the camera’s left, soft.
Black flag: a black card, about 60° to the camera’s right, soft.
- No fill: a black card on the shadow side keeps the shadows dark (negative fill).
- Shadow edges
- Shadows that fade gradually from light to dark, cast by a large or diffused light: a window, a softbox, a cloudy sky.
- Shadow depth
- Dark shadows that still hold some detail (a high lighting ratio, about 4:1 to 8:1: the shadow side two to three stops darker).
- Lit side of the face
- With the face turned, the side away from the camera is lit and the near side falls into shadow, so the face looks slimmer and more sculpted.
- Shape & form
- Light turning gradually into shade across faces and objects, so their volume shows.
- Highlights
- Even the brightest parts (clouds, white cloth, snow) keep texture and detail.
How the style is lit
- One large soft source high and to one side of the sitter and slightly in front, with no fill or only a faint bounce. The exemplars differ in the source: Carla van de Puttelaar works almost exclusively with daylight (her website; NOS has 'alleen met daglicht', only with daylight) and tells Sotheby's that being near a large window is critical, while Collectors Agenda's pictures of Hendrik Kerstens's studio show a large black softbox. The north window is the painters' reference, not documented practice; the placement high and to one side is inferred from the pictures.
- A black flag on the shadow side and the sitter several metres in front of a dark painted or cloth ground, so the ground stays near-black and the light falls off across the body.
- Short lighting: the face turned partly back towards the camera, the light on the far cheek, the near cheek and the shoulders in soft shadow.
This plan is worked out from the style’s choices, so it is drawn as a schematic. One way to get the light, not a record of how any photograph was lit.
Lens and settings
Start at
On a full-frame camera: the same depth of field and exposure as the style’s own numbers, in the same light. Then meter and adjust.
- Then
- 70–135 mm · f/4–f/11 · 1/125–1/30 s · ISO 100–800 on full frame, inferred from the gear and the look. Inferred from the look (a still sitter, a face sharp from ear to nose, a short telephoto perspective, a dark ground) and from window or soft studio light; no source gives the exemplars' camera or exposure. Daylight from a window needs a wider aperture, a tripod and a slower shutter; a strobe in a softbox allows f/8 at base ISO.
- White balance
- Daylight balance, graded to a neutral or slightly cool dark ground and pale skin; some makers grade a little warmer.
- Focal length
- Roughly the eye’s own perspective; no visible distortion.
- Angle
- The camera at the height of a standing person or of the subject.
- Distance
- Within arm’s reach: faces, hands and details fill the frame.
- Balance
- The subject in the middle, the frame balanced around it.
- Duration
- An unmoving scene, exposed slowly and carefully.
Direct
One sitter, half-length or head and shoulders, seated or standing still, the body turned three-quarters and the face turned back towards the lens, sometimes a glance over the shoulder. The face is composed and unsmiling, the mouth closed; the eyes meet the lens calmly, now and then lowered or resting just past it. Hands, if seen, lie at rest. Direct for stillness and quiet, not for expression.
- Whole body
- MustAsk for stillness: let the sitter settle into the pose before each frame, and change little between frames.Photographer directs. The face must stay sharp from ear to nose, and the stillness is part of the painted look.
- MustAdult sitters only; never generate a real or identifiable person, and never present the picture as a painting or as a copy of a named painting.Safety and consent. The best-known series began with a child sitter, and some practitioners photograph children; the entry keeps to adults.
- OptionalSeat the sitter upright on a stool or chair; standing still works as well.Photographer directs.
- Head and neck
- MustTurn the head until the light falls on the far cheek and the near cheek rests in soft shadow.Photographer directs. Short lighting gives the slow gradations of the painted portraits.
- MustDress the head: a folded white cloth, a bonnet, a hood or a velvet turban, or hair dressed in a period manner.Photographer directs. The headdress carries the reference to 17th-century painting while the rest stays plain.
- OptionalTurn the body further away and ask for a glance back over the shoulder.Photographer directs.
- AvoidDo not build the headdress from an everyday object (a napkin, a plastic bag, foil) to echo one living maker; commission or credit them instead.Photographer directs. Hendrik Kerstens's everyday-object headdresses are his own signature conceit.
- Face and eyes
- MustA composed, unsmiling face, the mouth closed and the eyes meeting the lens calmly.Photographer directs. The style directs for stillness and quiet, not for expression.
- UsuallyKeep the skin and hair natural or lightly groomed, with little visible make-up.Subject chooses.
- OptionalNow and then lower the eyes, or let them rest just past the lens.Photographer directs.
- AvoidNo smouldering glamour look and no laughter.Photographer directs. Hollywood glamour is this style's foil: keep the face composed and unglamorous.
- Hands
- OptionalIf the hands show, let them lie at rest, folded or in the lap, without gesture.Photographer directs.
- Torso and hips
- MustTurn the body three-quarters away from the light and turn the face partly back towards the lens.Photographer directs. The turn lets the shoulders and clothes fall into near-black while the light models the face.
- UsuallyDress the body in dark, unbranded clothes, such as a turtleneck or a high collar.Photographer directs.
Must: the look depends on it · Usually: what the style does most of the time · Optional: one possibility among others · Avoid: works against the look.
- With the sitter
- The sitter arranged and still, facing the camera.
- The set-up
- A scene staged and directed like a film still or a painting.
Style the set
The head is dressed and everything else is plain: a white cloth, bonnet, hood or velvet turban, or hair dressed in a period manner (Dolron's ribbon-wrapped braids), over black or dark, unbranded clothes such as a turtleneck or a high collar. Skin and hair look natural or lightly groomed, with little visible make-up. The set is only a dark, near-black or mottled painted ground; props, where there are any, are few and chosen for colour and texture. The colours of the clothes and headdress are planned: blacks and umbers with at most one accent of white or red.
- Clothes
- Period dress, fancy dress, stage costume or someone else’s clothes, worn to play a part rather than as one’s own. Simple, solid, unbranded clothes chosen so they do not distract from the face.
- Hair & make-up
- No visible make-up; skin, hair and blemishes as they are.
- Set & props
- A painted, cloth, paper or seamless backdrop behind the subject.
- Look of the styling
- Few, simple elements on clean surfaces, with space around them. Clothes, props and set kept to a few chosen colours that work together.
Finish
- Colour
- Colour held back towards grey. White balanced to the light, so whites stay white and skin, food and products keep their real colour, with no overall cast.
- Digital & other
- A modern digital camera: clean, detailed, neutral.
- Texture
- Smooth tones with no visible grain.
- Post-production
- Perfected skin and surfaces. Areas lightened and darkened by hand in printing.
- Shown as
- Each picture stands on its own. Pictures made and shown as a set.
- Shown in
- Large prints on the wall, like paintings.
Stay away from three-point light, direct on-camera flash, high-key, coloured gels, ring light, butterfly light, hard-edged shadows, flat form, smouldering look, laughing, full glamour make-up, teal & orange grade, visible grain, hdr & tone-mapped, snapshot, candid & unobserved and wide angle.
Before you shoot it
The best-known photographs show real, named people, and every leading maker is living and in copyright: Hendrik and Paula Kerstens, Carla van de Puttelaar, Desirée Dolron, Gemmy Woud-Binnendijk. Kerstens's everyday-object headdresses (a napkin, a plastic bag, foil) are his own signature conceit: credit and commission rather than copy them, and never put a living photographer's name in a prompt. This style is clothed portraiture; van de Puttelaar's nudes lie outside it.
A prompt for an image model
No prompt for this style
Behind its pictures: real, named sitters and living makers whose signature conceits the caution asks to credit and commission, not copy.
A generated image could pass as theirs or as a painting.
Kerstens's everyday-object headdresses are his own signature conceit: credit and commission rather than copy them, and never put a living photographer's name in a prompt. This style is clothed portraiture. Never generate real or identifiable people. The look borrows from paintings: do not present a photograph or generated image as a painting, as a copy of a named painting, or as carrying a museum's authority.
Work with photographers of this tradition, or take only its light and lens (the shoot sheet above) without its people, places or rituals.
Where to see it
From open collections, shown whole with their credits. Later photographs are linked, not shown, while they are in copyright.
In copyright, so linked
- Napkin , Hendrik Kerstens, 2009. Amsterdam Museum, inv. 753 (gift, 2012).
- Bag , Hendrik Kerstens, 2007. Hendrik Kerstens, 'When Painting and Photography Merge into One', The Low Countries, 23 November 2020.
- Red Turban , Hendrik Kerstens, 2015. Hendrik Kerstens, 'When Painting and Photography Merge into One', The Low Countries, 23 November 2020.
- Xteriors XVIII , Desiree Dolron, 2018. 1stDibs sale listing.
With other styles
The opposite: Hollywood glamour portraiture. Hollywood glamour uses hard spotlights, butterfly shadows and a hair light to make a star shine; use it as the foil and keep one soft side light and a composed, unglamorous face.
Pairs with Pictorialism. Borrow pictorialism's painterly ambition, but keep the face sharp and do the painting in light and in retouching rather than with a soft-focus lens or a gum print.
The opposite: Staged tableau photography. The staged tableau builds a whole scene with many lights and deep focus; use it when the story needs a room, and this style when one face against a dark ground is enough.
Pairs with Dark and moody food photography. Shares the single side window and dark ground; pair them for a portrait and a still life that hang together in one series or one menu.
The opposite: Boudoir photography. Boudoir turns soft light towards skin and desire; keep this style clothed, still and distant when the brief is portraiture, not sensuality.
Sources
- https://hendrikkerstens.com/
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hendrik_Kerstens
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taylor_Wessing_Photographic_Portrait_Prize
- https://www.collectorsagenda.com/en/in-the-studio/hendrik-kerstens
- https://www.the-low-countries.com/article/when-painting-and-photography-merge-into-one/
- https://danzigergallery.com/attachment/en/5abb9910a09a728e158b4568/TextOneColumnWithFile/5abb9959a09a728e158b5fa8
- https://am.adlibhosting.com/ais6v2/Details/museum/98710
- https://www.universiteitleiden.nl/in-de-media/2023/04/fotografie-hendrik-en-paula-kerstens-beschikbaar-in-digital-collections
- https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2013/12/23/kerstens-remakes-old-master-images
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carla_van_de_Puttelaar
- https://carlavandeputtelaar.com/
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desiree_Dolron
- https://nos.nl/artikel/2270165-fotograferen-a-la-rembrandt-een-zoektocht-naar-het-juiste-licht
- https://mymodernmet.com/gemmy-woud-binnendijk-fine-art-photography
- https://www.1stdibs.com/art/photography/portrait-photography/desiree-dolron-xteriors-xviii/id-a_15353332
- https://sothebys.com/en/articles/breathtaking-portraits-celebrate-the-women-of-the-art-world